eJournal Archive Package (2005-1962): Details on request.

Archive (2005–1962)

Quality Assessments of HMO Diagnosis Databases Used to Monitor Childhood Vaccine Safety

Journal: Methods Archive
ISSN: 0026-1270
Issue: 2004 (Vol. 43): Issue 2 2004
Pages: 163-170

Quality Assessments of HMO Diagnosis Databases Used to Monitor Childhood Vaccine Safety

J. Mullooly (1), L. Drew (1), F. DeStefano (2), J. Maher (3), K. Bohlke (4), V. Immanuel (4), S. Black (5), E. Lewis (5), P. Ray (5), C. Vadheim (6), M. Lugg (6), R. Chen (2)

(1) Center for Health Research, Kaiser Permanente Northwest, Portland, Oregon, USA (2) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA (3) Oregon Department of Human Services, Portland, Oregon, USA (4) Group Health Cooperative, Seattl


Quality Control, Databases, health maintenance organizations, International Classification of Diseases (ICD-9), vaccines


Objective: To assess the quality of automated diagnoses extracted from medical care databases by the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) study. Methods: Two methods are used to assess quality of VSD diagnosis data. The first method compares common automated and abstracted diagnostic categories ("outcomes") in 1-2% simple random samples of study populations. The second method estimates positive predictive values of automated diagnosis codes used to identify potential cases of rare conditions (e.g., acute ataxia) for inclusion in nested case-control medical record abstraction studies. Results: There was good agreement (64-68%) between automated and abstracted outcomes in the 1-2% simple random samples at 3 of the 4 VSD sites and poor agreement (44%) at 1 site. Overall at 3 sites, 56% of children with automated cerebella ataxia codes (ICD-9 = 334) and 22% with "lack of coordination" codes (ICD-9 = 781.3) met objective clinical criteria for acute ataxia. Conclusions: The misclassification error rates for automated screening outcomes substantially reduce the power of screening analyses and limit usefulness of screening analyses to moderate to strong vaccine-outcome associations. Medical record verification of outcomes is needed for definitive assessments.

You may also be interested in...


B. Diallo, J.-M. Travere, B. Mazoyer

Methods Inf Med 1999 38 2: 132-139


F. Muranaga 1, I. Kumamoto 2, Y. Uto2

Methods Inf Med 2007 46 6: 679-685

Emmanuel J. Favaloro 1, Roslyn Bonar 1, Muriel Meiring 2, Alison Street 1, Katherine Marsden 1, on behalf of the RCPA QAP in Haematology

Thromb Haemost 2007 98 2: 346-358